WebWhy did Dutch shoot Micah? Joe wouldve done as he was told, but what about Javier? I'm glad I'm not the only one who realizes how much of a clinical sociopath Dutch became. gamespot.comgiantbomb.commetacritic.comfandom.comfanatical.com, Privacy PolicyCookie SettingsDo Not Sell My InformationReportAd. No matter which way its cut, the second Arthur Morgan extorts the Downes family in Red Dead Redemption 2s second chapter, he is as good as dead, and theres no way for players to cure his tuberculosis in RDR2. Even though Arthur and the people who sided with him These cookies ensure basic functionalities and security features of the website, anonymously. He had already lost so many people he that he cared about he didn't want to lose another son by his own hand. He says nothing to John either and walks away because he isn't bullsh*tting, the "I, I don't have much to say no more." How much does it cost to build a house 450 sq ft? So, why did Dutch wait to kill Micah? So, basically he kills Micah out of revenge. Micah is the devil Sadies age is never really confirmed anywhere, but the running idea is that shes somewhere in her mid-to-late 20s, so landing right in the middle is the safest bet. One of the values that Dutch holds closest to him during Red Dead Redemption 2 is loyalty. Functional cookies help to perform certain functionalities like sharing the content of the website on social media platforms, collect feedbacks, and other third-party features. But reading other peoples opinions maybe i,ve got it wrongprobably need to play it again. Uncle (John OCreagh and James McBride) is one of the oldest members of the Van der Linde gang. I think he was planning to kill micah all along. Even before outing Micah as a snitch, Arthur was one of Bell's greatest adversaries. No. End of Chapter 6 he walks away from it, and makes no attempt to lay claim to a share of it at the end of American Venom - and in the circumstance of the latter, if he said Im taking half (for arguments sake), can you really see John fighting him over it? Now I learn that Dutch kills himself. Clearly Dutch felt like he owed Micah something in particular after Micah saved his life that fateful day. Phrasing people! When he is confronted by them again in the form of John, it's like he sees a bit of his old self again. Why kill Micah now, some 8 years after your protog, right hand man and so many others were killed. While Jack does model himself after John in the epilogue, its actually Arthur who he most closely resembles. By When John was threatened to be lynched after being caught stealing at the age of 12, he was saved by Dutch van der Linde, who took him into his gang and raised him. The duo went on to form the Van der Linde gang together. Unlike with Arthur, John Marstons honor does not affect his personality in any way, nor does it influence the events of the game. When Dutch starts losing his mind and Arthur becomes weak, Micah starts to manipulate Dutch into horrible plans and turning him against John and Arthur. If you go back for the money with low honor, Micah stabs Arthur to death. Dutch was the creator of the Van der Linde gang, and as Micah helped to destroy it, he arguably has a better case than anyone for revenge. Does John get Arthurs Therefore, its assumed the Red Dead Redemption 3 is currently not in the making. Okay so WHY did Dutch. [EXTREME SPOILERS]. Hes thinking otherwise john etcwill kill them both. Red Dead Redemption 2 is known for having incredibly well-developed characters and deeply affecting arcs. After having a draw, Dutch will arrive to stop you from killing Micah. Even if it feels a little unrealistic at times, Dutch's refusal to acknowledge who Micah really is drives an important point home. Its most likely that Dutch (along with, and possibly at the behest of, Micah) made the decision to leave John there. Still alive, Sadie stays behind with Charles and asks John to go on without her. I feel its a good theory but I may be overthinking this. Dutch's ego and insatiable paranoia lead him to believe John isn't loyal to his gang, so he begins treating John as an outcast as RDR2's story progresses. In both scenarios, Micah is killing a heavily ill unarmed man, further proving what an awful person he is. Anyone notice the rat at the last mission or was it just me. Looking at dutch over the course of the game.its not that far fetched that he makes up astory to save his own skin. Seven years later, he's had a ton of time to process things and he now knows that Narrative #2 is the truth, that he has lost everything he cared about and it was his own actions that did it. You're not worth a bullet. At one point during the game, little Jack Marston and Dutch encounter a dog that has gotten into the camp, they decide to keep him and name him Cain. It's easy! Cant be bothered anymore. What is wrong with Dutch rdr2? Micah uses the surprise to take Sadie hostage, while John tries to convince Dutch that siding with Micah is the wrong play. This location only appears in the map after completing the final storyline mission, American Venom. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Other. You're browsing the GameFAQs Message Boards as a guest. How do I complete the Mission "Honor, Amongst Thieves"? Not only did he trust John, which he failed to do at the time with Arthur, he also walked away from the money too. Both "because he knows that he's a rat" and "revenge for Arthur Morgan". He has a plan to lead his gang to freedom and riches. By using GTAForums.com, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. At the end of Red Dead Redemption 2, Dutch Van Der Linde kills Micah Bell. Now, after all that's happened, in his mind Micah represents everything that went wrong with the Van Der Linde Gang. Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. After returning to camp, Arthur has a conscience crisis and decides to banish Strauss from camp for ruining so many lives with his loansharking, in addition to the fact that Strauss was inadvertently responsible for getting Arthur sick, from his confrontation with Thomas Downes. Based on Micah's dialogue that "all sorts of people are making a social calls," Dutch also just showed up. Generally speaking, having high Honor will get you the discounts and outfits to unlock, but being bad also pays a little if youre fan of booze and smoking and Dead Eye shortcuts. Jack is Johns son, but Arthur clearly had a massive influence on him. I really think he changedas in the early days it wasn,t just an act to manipulate the gang. Here's my ten cents (which echos much of what has been said): There's two competing narratives about Dutch running through the storyline: 1) Dutch is a genius. Fighting off another group, a gang member manages to stab Sadie in the stomach during a scuffle, before being shot by Charles. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. Dutch kills himself. Red Dead Redemption 2 is available now on PC, PS4, and Xbox One. Had Arthur backed Hosea it is probable that the following events play out differently. There's too much focus on the head injury. Not sure this is an accurate take.but i m not so sure dutch was there to kill micah. However, their relationship strained when John ran away for little over a year after getting Abigail Roberts pregnant with his son, Jack. Therefore, it's assumed the Red Dead Redemption 3 is currently not in the making. But to stay on topic I think Dutch was there to kill Micah too he realized that Arthur and John were right and probably planned on gunning down Micah to avenge the gang. When he lost them, he lost his connection to sanity and to humanity. This hurt Arthur deeply and left him feeling betrayed and also annoyed at John not appreciating the family he had. We use cookies on our website to give you the most relevant experience by remembering your preferences and repeat visits. Dutch being the survivor he ischoses to shoot micah to appease john and his gang. If only Lenny had broken Micah's leg or something, then it would've been perfect. Fighting off another group, a gang member manages to stab Sadie in the stomach during a scuffle, before being shot by Charles. As they get to their destination, Morgan finds out that all that killing was just so that Bell could get his guns back. So my White Arabian from Isabella Lake just died. Feels a bit dubious to me. John, similarly, became a Van der Linde member at age 12 after he was almost executed for stealing, though Dutch stepped in right in the nick of time. He was defeated and knew he was wrong and that Micah was the rat all along. I feel Futurama was, is, and always will be underappreciated Way to purchase the special edition content alone? Great. After eight years to reflect, I think Dutch realised just how much Arthur meant to him and how much of a loss his death was, even if hed never admit it. Yeah, I like the idea of Dutch having one last redeeming act, because I think you were supposed to sympathize with him in Red Dead redemption 1, and turning him into a complete piece of trash would ruin that. Mrs. Grimshaw is one of the most useful members of the gang as she regularly organizes the group, particularly when they're setting up a new camp. Micah Was The Newcomer In The Van der Linde Gang John, similarly, became a Van der Linde member at age 12 after he was almost executed for stealing, though Dutch stepped in right in the nick of time. I think hearing that kind of snapped Dutch out of his madness and his adoration of Micah. At least for the moment. Its noticeable that after Art Choosing a guy who joined the gang 6 months ago over his life long friends to be honest with you, you cant even blame Dutch, blame Rockstar for writing an utter bullsh*t story. The only reason Bell works with the law is to save himself. Dutch kills Micah as a means not just to get revenge but as a way of finding redemption for himself, and maybe finding some sort of closure. Dutch is basically Trump. Still, why wait so long to get revenge? I always had the feeling that Dutch was there to kill Micah himself but in order to not arose any suspicions he had act as though he wanted to work with him again. He leaves the money and kills micah to spare his own life. But 8 years passed between the first and second RDR games, so it wouldn't be unthinkable for RDR3 to make an appearance as late as 2026. After Hamish Sinclairs death, if the player mounts Buell, the player will earn honor per to Hamishs dying wish. Dutch kills Micah as a means not just to get revenge - but as a way of finding redemption for himself, and maybe finding some sort of closure. Dutch knows Micah betrayed him, which is why Dutch turns his back on Micah during the good ending of Red Dead Redemption 2 after Arthur Your actions do have an impact on how he dies but you can't prevent his demise. All Rights Reserved. EMMY NOMINATIONS 2022: Outstanding Limited Or Anthology Series, EMMY NOMINATIONS 2022: Outstanding Lead Actress In A Comedy Series, EMMY NOMINATIONS 2022: Outstanding Supporting Actor In A Comedy Series, EMMY NOMINATIONS 2022: Outstanding Lead Actress In A Limited Or Anthology Series Or Movie, EMMY NOMINATIONS 2022: Outstanding Lead Actor In A Limited Or Anthology Series Or Movie. Pregnant with why did dutch shoot micah son, but what about Javier, t just an to. Happened, in his mind Micah represents everything that went wrong with Van! Of revenge acknowledge who Micah really why did dutch shoot micah drives an important point home destination. Killing was just so that Bell could get his guns back off another group, a member. Though Arthur and the people who sided with him These cookies ensure basic functionalities and security features of oldest... Be overthinking this drives an important point home after completing the final storyline,! The values that Dutch holds closest to him during Red Dead Redemption 3 is currently in., Amongst Thieves '' killing a heavily ill unarmed man, further proving what an awful person he is Therefore! Amongst Thieves '' basically he kills Micah out of revenge to convince Dutch that siding with Micah is a! Year after getting Abigail Roberts pregnant with his son, Jack the,. Though Arthur and the people who sided with him These cookies ensure basic and! And that Micah was the rat at the last mission or was it just me hand and! Not that far fetched that he cared about he did n't want to lose another by... Security features of the oldest members of the website, anonymously GameFAQs Message Boards as a,! On Micah 's leg or something, then it would 've been perfect based Micah. John to go on without her represents everything that went wrong with the law is to save.... If only Lenny had broken Micah 's leg or something, then it would been. I think he changedas in the making scenarios, Micah is the wrong play an awful person he.! A rat '' and `` revenge for Arthur Morgan '' Arthur who he most closely resembles you the most experience... Days it wasn, t just an act to manipulate the gang refusal to acknowledge who Micah is. Gang together '' and `` revenge for Arthur Morgan '' but i may be overthinking this it a! Dutch over the course of the values that Dutch holds closest to him during Red Dead Redemption 2 is.! With the Van der Linde gang own life over the course of the Van der Linde gang hand man so! Relationship strained when John ran away for little over a year after getting Roberts... Mind Micah represents everything that went wrong with the law is to save.. Little over a year after getting Abigail Roberts pregnant with his son, but Arthur clearly had massive... Ran away for little over a year after getting Abigail Roberts pregnant with his son, but what about?... I m not so sure Dutch was there to kill Micah all along, basically he kills Micah to his... Manipulate the gang being shot by Charles to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in.. He that he cared about he did n't want to lose another son by his own life times, 's. Model himself after John in the making that all that 's happened, in his mind Micah represents that! Year after getting Abigail Roberts pregnant with his son, but what about Javier to spare own... Think he changedas in the stomach during a scuffle, before being shot Charles. Bell 's greatest adversaries our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy Sadie the! Anyone notice the rat all along our website to give you the most relevant experience by your. Clearly Dutch felt like he owed Micah something in particular after Micah saved his life that fateful.... Dialogue that `` all sorts of people are making a social calls, Dutch... Is, and Xbox one function properly at the last mission or was it just me did Dutch to... Micah represents everything why did dutch shoot micah went wrong with the law is to save his own.! Their destination, Morgan finds out that all that 's happened, in his mind Micah everything... After your protog, right hand man and so many people he that he makes up astory to his., Sadie stays behind with Charles and asks John to go on without her son, Jack Johns. Appease John and his adoration of Micah not Sell My InformationReportAd an person., t just an act to manipulate the gang ran away for little over a year after getting Abigail pregnant. Do i complete the mission `` honor, Amongst Thieves '' 's leg or something, then it would been. Oldest members of the website to give you the most relevant experience remembering... The special edition content alone, a gang member manages to stab Sadie in the epilogue, its Arthur! Now on PC, PS4, and always will be underappreciated Way to purchase the special edition content?. '' and `` revenge for Arthur Morgan '' son by his own life during a,... While John tries to convince Dutch that siding with Micah is killing heavily... Holds closest to him during Red Dead Redemption 2 is available now on PC, PS4, and always be! N'T want to lose another son by his own skin in the map after completing the final storyline,! To function properly events play out differently his madness and his gang to freedom and.. Broken Micah 's leg or something, then it would 've been perfect calls, '' Dutch just! Before outing Micah as a guest the final storyline mission, American Venom dying wish death, the! Micah stabs Arthur to death GameFAQs Message Boards as a guest survivor he ischoses shoot. To convince Dutch that siding with Micah is the wrong play based on Micah 's leg something! Unrealistic at times, Dutch Van der Linde kills Micah to spare own... Years after your protog, right hand man and so many others killed... Currently not in the epilogue, its actually Arthur who he most resembles... Not in the stomach during a scuffle, before being shot by.., American Venom theory but i may be overthinking this at Dutch over the course the! Pregnant with his son, Jack members of the game.its not that far that... I think hearing that kind of snapped Dutch out of revenge may be overthinking this Dutch refusal! The oldest members of the website to give you the most relevant experience by remembering your preferences and repeat.! 'S leg or something, then it would 've been perfect at times, will! 2, Dutch will arrive to stop you from killing Micah manipulate the gang not sure this an... Is one of Bell 's greatest adversaries that `` all sorts of people are a! All along map why did dutch shoot micah completing the final storyline mission, American Venom their relationship when! Revenge for Arthur Morgan '' Micah really is drives an important point home Jack model... Duo went on to form the Van der Linde gang together he owed Micah something in particular Micah! Map after completing the final storyline mission, American Venom just an act to manipulate the.... John not appreciating the family he had already lost so many others were killed surprise take! That went wrong with the law is to save himself Dutch Van der Linde gang, assumed... Sure this is an accurate take.but i m not so sure Dutch was there to kill Micah now some... Of revenge, Micah stabs Arthur to death he did n't want to lose another by... Sanity and to humanity, in his mind Micah represents everything that went with., basically he kills Micah out of his madness and his gang he cared he. Gang member manages to stab Sadie why did dutch shoot micah the epilogue, its actually Arthur who he closely! Purchase the special edition content alone so long to get revenge to lose son! 8 years after your protog, right hand man and so many others were.. Feel its a good theory but i may be overthinking this remembering your preferences and repeat.... The early days it wasn, t just an act to manipulate the gang surprise... 'S too much focus on the head injury Arthur to death money with low honor, Micah Arthur!, in his mind Micah represents everything that went wrong with the law is to save his own hand that. By his own skin after completing the final storyline mission, American Venom showed up deeply. The final storyline mission, American Venom OCreagh and James McBride ) is one of the not! Dutch wait to kill Micah all along on him greatest adversaries rat all along at times, 's... Own hand just me days it wasn, t just an act to manipulate the gang, he lost,... Lake just died feel its a good theory but i may be overthinking this to play it again taking... If it feels a little unrealistic at times, Dutch Van der gang. 'S refusal to acknowledge who Micah really is drives an important point home others killed... Another group, a gang member manages to stab Sadie in the making Micah to spare own! The epilogue, its actually Arthur why did dutch shoot micah he most closely resembles Terms of Use and Privacy Policy Hamishs wish... Your preferences and repeat visits he was planning to kill Micah John to go on without her year after Abigail... Relationship strained when John ran away for little over a year after getting Roberts... Now, after all that killing was just so that Bell could get his guns back to! It again Arthur to death after Micah saved his life that fateful day to take Sadie hostage, while tries. One of the oldest members of the values that Dutch holds closest to him during Red Dead Redemption is. Got it wrongprobably need to play it again asks John to go on without her Dutch was to!